pieve santa restituta (gaja), brunello di montalcino, sugarille 2007

pieve santa restituta (gaja), brunello di montalcino, sugarille 2007
VINOUS
96
JAMES SUCKLING
95

Critics' Scores

  • VINOUS
    96
    Vinous

    The 2007 Brunello di Montalcino Sugarille is dazzling. Dark fruit, tar, licorice and smoke come to life in this dramatic, large-scaled Brunello. The 2007 boasts incredible intensity and power all the way through to the palate-staining finish. Today the tannins are big and imposing, but they should start settling down as the wine approaches its tenth birthday. I saw the wine shut down quickly in the glass, which is an excellent sign for its potential longevity. This is a flat-out gorgeous bottle of wine.

  • JAMES SUCKLING
    95
    James Suckling

    Aromas of dried berries and chocolate follow through to a full body, with velvety tannins and a lot of fruit. Balanced and delicious. Impressive wine that shows superb depth of fruit.

  • STEPHEN TANZER
    95
    Stephen Tanzer

    Bright, deep red. Higher-toned and more floral on the nose than the Rennina, showing pungent red cherry, marzipan, gingerbread and Asian spice aromas. Concentrated and penetrating in the mouth, boasting a more chiseled texture and more lift than the Rennina but still wonderfully ripe, dense and silky in the style of 2007. Finishes with very sweet, lush tannins and excellent structure and nerve for a graceful evolution in bottle.

  • WINE ENTHUSIAST
    94
    Wine Enthusiast

    Bold and elegant at the same time. Packs a powerful punch in a silk glove. Intense aromas of ripe fruit, spice, cherry liqueur, cola, dried sage and cigar box. The mouthfeel is pristine and structured, with a precise, tonic and streamlined impact.

  • WINE SPECTATOR
    92
    Wine Spectator

    A smooth, fleshy red, with cherry, licorice and leather flavors matched to a firm, pliable structure. Opulent and balanced, with bright acidity as well as grip on the finish. Best from 2014 through 2027. 250 cases imported.

Simple, modern wine investing

Intelligently add wine to a diversified portfolio you can savor.

two glasses
three glasses