Top 5 Fine Wine Regions for Investment Returns

Fine wine has quietly become one of the most resilient alternative assets, offering investors a rare blend of steady returns, diversification, and protection against inflation. With global indices like the Liv-ex Fine Wine 1000 significantly outperforming many traditional assets over the past decade, demand for investment-grade bottles continues to rise among high-net-worth and institutional investors alike. But not all wine regions deliver the same results. From the established dominance of Bordeaux to the scarcity-driven gains of Burgundy and the growing momentum of regions like Tuscany, Champagne, and Napa Valley, certain markets consistently stand out. Below, we break down the top five fine wine regions with the strongest historical investment returns and explain why they can fit into a modern, diversified portfolio.

Fine wine has delivered strong long-term performance in some benchmarks, but results depend on timing, region, producer, vintage selection, and total carrying costs. For context, the Liv-ex Investables Index shows a return of about 2,050% since 1988 (as of July 2024).

Quick Highlights:

• Bordeaux: The largest, most liquid region in fine wine trading, representing about 41-42% of traded value on Liv-ex in recent market snapshots.
• Burgundy: The scarcity play. Top producers can post huge runs. One example is Domaine Leroy (2014 Vosne-Romanée Aux Genaivrières) at +503% over 5 years in a tracked performance example.
• Tuscany: Super Tuscans have been steady compounders. Decanter notes they have tripled in price over the last decade, supported by global demand and strong brand pull.
• Champagne: A top-performing collectible category over the long haul, with a +291.5% total return since 2004 in a Liv-ex 1000 regional breakdown; standout vintages like 2002 Salon have been cited at +225% over 5 years in market commentary.
• Napa Valley: Cult Cabernet is a smaller market, but prices can move fast. One example is 1998 Screaming Eagle, which rose +72% from Aug 2021 to Jul 2023 in tracked secondary pricing.

Fine wine remains a niche market but is growing, driven by limited production, increasing global demand, and rising interest from ultra wealthy investors.. Whether you're diversifying your portfolio or seeking stable returns, these regions offer compelling opportunities.

1. Bordeaux, France

Bordeaux is the most established region for fine wine investing and a major driver of secondary-market activity. In 2023, Bordeaux accounted for around 40% of trades by value on Liv-ex. [5]. Its wines have shown impressive returns: 27% over 5 years, 84% over a decade, and 174% over 15 years [6].

This region's reputation is built on its historic estates and esteemed châteaux. Names like Lafite Rothschild, Latour, and Margaux have a strong track record of increasing in value. For example, the 2001 La Mission Haut-Brion saw a 311% return over 15 years, while the 2001 Petrus delivered 282% [6].

"Bordeaux remains the most important wine investment region, accounting for over a third of the fine wine market by value today with a 200% average growth on top labels since 2005." - WineCap [7]

Bordeaux’s success is supported by strict production limits and the small size of its vineyards. Since 1988, the Liv-ex Investables Index has grown by 2,050% [2].

Adding to its appeal:

"Bordeaux is the epicenter of fine wine production, offering some of the most distinctive, most exotic, and greatest wines." - Robert Parker, Wine Advocate [5]

The Bordeaux En Primeur system also plays a role, increasing liquidity and making wines accessible beyond the First Growths. This is further fueled by growing demand in Asia.

For the best returns, consider vintages from top producers in standout years like 2005, 2009, 2010, and 2016. Ensure purchases are made through trusted platforms that verify authenticity and provide proper storage.

2. Burgundy, France

Burgundy offers a stark contrast to Bordeaux, with its focus on limited production and emphasis on terroir. Burgundy is a scarcity-driven market. Limited production and high demand can push prices up quickly, but Burgundy can also swing harder during broader market pullbacks. Production here is much smaller compared to Bordeaux. Take Domaine de la Romanée-Conti, for example - it produces fewer than 6,000 bottles a year, while some Bordeaux estates churn out 20,000 cases [8].

This scarcity has fueled impressive returns over the past five years:

The Cult Wines Burgundy Index has grown by +135.52% since January 2014 [12], reflecting the increasing demand for Burgundy wines amid their limited availability [9].

"Limited quantity and exceptional quality are a combination that only increases demand." - Guy Woodward, Wine Expert [8]

Burgundy's value is further underscored by record-breaking sales, such as three bottles of Domaine Leroy Musigny selling for $47,333 each in 2021 [9].

For those interested in investing, buying wines en primeur (before bottling) can offer access to coveted allocations at potentially lower prices [10]. Exceptional vintages, like 2015, are particularly worth considering for their strong appreciation potential.

"The principle of scarcity has an undeniable pull that shapes market dynamics and prices." - Marc Lafleur, Wine Investment Expert [11]

With rising global interest, especially from Asian markets [13], and its family-owned vineyards and limited production, Burgundy continues to see strong value growth across the fine wine market.

3. Tuscany, Italy

Tuscany has emerged as a top destination for fine wine investments. In 2024, its commercial value climbed by 16.1%, while Italian wine trade volume grew by 17.6% [17][18].

Super Tuscans have built strong demand on the secondary market. Introduced by Sassicaia in 1968, these wines blend international grape varieties with the local Sangiovese, reshaping Italian wine investment.

Here’s a snapshot of key Super Tuscans and their performance:

"Super Tuscans have lived up to their label, tripling in price over the last decade."
Ella Lister, Wine Investment Analyst [14]

One of Tuscany's key advantages is its production scale. Unlike Burgundy, where limited quantities can restrict liquidity, Super Tuscans offer ample supply, making them attractive for larger investment positions. As a result, wine funds are increasingly allocating 2-3% of their portfolios to Italian wines [14].

The U.S. market has also played a crucial role, with Italian wine purchases surging by 69.3%. Competitive pricing compared to French wines and consistently high quality ratings have further fueled demand. For instance, the 2020 vintage of Tignanello earned an impressive 96 points from Antonio Galloni [16].

"Super Tuscans are a key part of our investment strategy, and we encourage clients to consider incorporating these wines into a diversified portfolio."
Cult Wines [15]

For investors, established labels like Sassicaia offer stability, while emerging names such as Guado al Tasso provide entry level opportunities [16]. Tuscany also stands out for its steadier performance compared to the more volatile Bordeaux market [14].

The introduction of the IGT classification in 1992 gave these wines formal recognition, further boosting their appeal. Over the past decade, Super Tuscans have outperformed Piedmont wines by a wide margin - 142% versus 43% [14]. These factors firmly position Tuscany as a major player in fine wine investment.

Up next: Champagne, France, where a different set of market trends offers unique investment opportunities.

4. Champagne, France

Champagne has become a major player in the fine wine investment world. Since 2004, it has ranked as the second best performing segment in the Liv-ex 1000 index, delivering a total return of 291.5% and an annual growth rate of 8.9% [19].

What makes Champagne stand out? Its limited production and high demand. With annual production capped at around 300 million bottles and only a few vintage releases, scarcity plays a big role in driving up its value. The Liv-ex Champagne 50 index, for example, recorded a 51.30% rise in value over five years [4].

Here’s how some top vintages have performed:

The market for prestige cuvées is especially strong. Take the 2005 Jacques Selosse Millesimé, for instance. With just 4,000 bottles produced, its scarcity has driven impressive returns [23]. Similarly, the 2002 Salon vintage, limited to 60,000 bottles, has seen substantial appreciation, supported by high-quality ratings of 97 from Vinous and 95 from Wine Advocate[23].

"The craftsmanship, increasing rarity and ageing potential of the great Champagnes will always find willing buyers."
Justin Gibbs, Co-founder of Liv-ex [22]

Recent price trends also highlight Champagne's strength. For example, Cristal 2013 rose by 40%, Dom Pérignon P2 1998 by 39%, and Cristal 2004 by 39% [19]. Projections suggest the Champagne market will grow from $6.7 billion in 2023 to $10.2 billion by 2033 [20].

"The quality/price ratio of prestige Cuvee Champagne has been undervalued for a long time. When compared to high end Bordeaux or Burgundy, prestige Cuvee Champagne is still selling at a fraction of the price, however that gap is closing."
Rostislav Petrov, Associate Director, Cru Wine[21]

For investors, vintage Champagne offers clear advantages over non-vintage options. Exceptional vintages with longer aging potential, such as Dom Pérignon, Krug, and Salon, are particularly rewarding [21]. The Liv-ex Champagne 50 index also saw a 94% surge between April 2020 and October 2022 [22]. With growing interest from markets like Asia, vintage Champagne remains a strong choice for diversifying a fine wine portfolio.

5. Napa Valley, USA

Napa Valley's cult wines have carved out a strong position in the fine wine investment world. The California 50 index reflected this strength, showing a 16.5% growth in 2021, surpassing both Bordeaux and Italy in performance [25]. This highlights the region's increasing appeal to investors.

Screaming Eagle, one of Napa's most sought-after wineries, produces only 700–850 cases annually, making its wines highly scarce and desirable. Its wines have shown impressive returns:

The inaugural 1992 Screaming Eagle Cabernet Sauvignon is a standout example of Napa's investment potential. Scoring 99 points from Robert Parker, a 6-liter bottle of this vintage sold for an astounding $500,000 at Auction Napa Valley in 2000, setting a high bar for premium Napa wines.

Over the years, Napa Valley's cabernet prices have skyrocketed, increasing from $461 per ton in 1976 to $8,813 in 2022 [24]. Meanwhile, the number of producers has grown by about 4% annually [24].

"The wine industry is at a tipping point... the convergence of an aging population and decelerating population growth signals a future with fewer consumers on the hunt for expensive wine." - Tim Carl, Napa Valley Features [24]

For investors, ensuring authenticity is critical, as counterfeits are a known issue in the secondary market. Joining cult winery mailing lists can provide direct access to limited releases, often at more favorable initial prices. For example, the 2007 Screaming Eagle Cabernet Sauvignon, which earned a perfect 100-point score from Robert Parker, demonstrates how high critic scores can influence value.

In 2022, a collection of three magnum bottles from Screaming Eagle (Cabernet Sauvignon, The Flight, and Sauvignon Blanc) sold for $48,600 at Sotheby's, proving that demand remains strong.

Platforms like Vinovest simplify access to Napa wines, but investors should diversify their portfolios as market conditions shift. Napa Valley continues to hold a distinct place in fine wine investment, offering unique opportunities for those navigating this evolving market.

Conclusion

Fine wine can be a useful portfolio diversifier, but it still moves in cycles. That is why region selection, producer quality, provenance, and total costs matter as much as headline returns.

Bordeaux remains the liquidity anchor. Burgundy is scarcity-driven and can swing more. Champagne, Tuscany, and Napa can add diversification through different demand drivers and collector bases.

Platforms like Vinovest help investors handle authentication, storage, and access. Recent price corrections in established regions may also create opportunities for long term buyers. The practical approach is to focus on liquidity, verified provenance, and a diversified mix of regions and producers, with a multi year holding period.

• Want exposure to top regions without doing the sourcing and storage yourself?
• Sign up on Vinovest, and all else will be taken care of for you.